Valves (24V) comes on, but don't shut off with Rachio 3

I have 2 Valves that opens without problems, but they don’t close when told to by the Rachio app.
I’ve tried different zones on the Rachio and same problem.
I’ve disconnecting 1 of the 2 valves and then the Valves shut off as intended.
I don’'t know what the problem is. Ive cleaned the Valves, but they weren’t dirty either.

Did this just start happening, but they worked properly before? I recently had a valve get stuck on and I had to replace it.